AquaRank.com

Review Proposed Changes

Profile:Gomphosus varius
Field:markings
Status:Approved
Votes:8
Submitter:sirbooks
Reason:
Old Text:Not SpecifiedNew Text:No Markings
Votes
MemberVoteWeight
LindyApprove4
CalilasseiaApprove2
sirbooksNeutral0
mrwizerdApprove2
Total: 8
Comments
sirbooks
Post InfoPosted 15-Sep-2006 03:17Profile MSN PM Edit Report 
Natalie
I would consider the light green patch behind the pectoral fins to be some sort of marking, but I don't know what it would be classified as...
Post InfoPosted 15-Sep-2006 08:44Profile Homepage AIM MSN PM Edit Report 
mrwizerdApprove
Post InfoPosted 16-Sep-2006 08:12Profile Homepage ICQ AIM MSN Yahoo PM Edit Report 
LindyApprove
Post InfoPosted 17-Sep-2006 07:11Profile PM Edit Report 
CalilasseiaApprove
Trouble with this fish is that it doesn't have large area markings of the kind that neatly fit into the drop down combo box categories. It does have some markings as an adult (and in fact undergoes some interesting colour changes as a juvenile) but the drop down combo box can't encapsulate all of that! I'll vote "approve" on the basis that the main body of the fish is effectively a 'plain canvas' of green as an adult. However, at some point, we'll probably need some photos to illustrate this fish in different growth stages, and possibly update the comments field to alert the user to go take a peek at them when they exist. I'll run with this one because [1] it's factually correct, and [2] the level of nit picking required to reject it isn't justified.
Post InfoPosted 17-Sep-2006 15:42Profile Homepage PM Edit Report