AquaRank.com

FishProfiles.com Message Forums

faq | etiquette | register | my account | search | mailbox
# FishProfiles.com Message Forums
L# Freshwater Aquaria
 L# Planted Aquaria
  L# Good Algae Eater for a Planted Tanks?
 Post Reply  New Topic
SubscribeGood Algae Eater for a Planted Tanks?
Cichlid Kid
****
-----
Fish Addict
Posts: 553
Kudos: 285
Votes: 34
Registered: 22-May-2004
male usa
i have a 10 G with some guppy fry and an Anubias.im going to my lfs today and probably wil pick up another anubias,and also i would like to get and algae eater,any recommendations on one that wont eat my plants,and will eat brown algae?also how about one for a cold water tank with goldfish, as my mom has some and would like one but most algae eater i know are tropical and would not be practical in that tank.so one algea eater for me and one for my mom,any suggestions?
Post InfoPosted 20-Jan-2009 22:14Profile AIM PM Edit Report 
riri1
*****
----------
Fish Addict
Posts: 537
Kudos: 435
Votes: 44
Registered: 04-Mar-2005
male
a gara is fine in cold water and u could go with some florida flagfish in the planted tank or some of the smaller plecos.
Post InfoPosted 20-Jan-2009 22:52Profile AIM PM Edit Delete Report 
Cichlid Kid
****
-----
Fish Addict
Posts: 553
Kudos: 285
Votes: 34
Registered: 22-May-2004
male usa
how about an otto?
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 00:32Profile AIM PM Edit Delete Report 
Shinigami
 
---------------
---------------
---------------
Ichthyophile
Catfish/Oddball Fan
Posts: 9962
Kudos: 2915
Registered: 22-Feb-2001
male usa us-delaware
No, ottos require groups, so one otto would not be a good idea. They also do need warmer water.

Since your tank is newly set-up, you're probably just going through an early phase. If you wait a few more weeks the brown algae may even disappear.

--------------------------------------------
The aquarist is one who must learn the ways of the biologist, the chemist, and the veterinarian.
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 01:19Profile PM Edit Delete Report 
riri1
*****
----------
Fish Addict
Posts: 537
Kudos: 435
Votes: 44
Registered: 04-Mar-2005
male
there was the 12 foot by 4 foot tank they had a school of like 160 or 200 ottos it was pretty sweet to see them swim in a group srry to derail from the subject but It was cool.
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 03:28Profile AIM PM Edit Delete Report 
Cichlid Kid
****
-----
Fish Addict
Posts: 553
Kudos: 285
Votes: 34
Registered: 22-May-2004
male usa
yes, that would be cool. and ive tried less light for a week w.no success, i want the light on top veiw the fish and if i do this the algae comes back.my tank is about 75F, but often times warmer
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 03:48Profile AIM PM Edit Delete Report 
brandeeno
 
-----
Mega Fish
Posts: 929
Kudos: 636
Registered: 13-Sep-2007
male usa us-california
get some cheap CAE or SAE and use those... SAE are better but IMO CAE are cheap and do the job well... although when they get older they might get aggressive (so oscar might find a new tank mate or a nice meal...)

SAE are more timid and keep to algae consumption and cleaning up leftovers, best bet if you can get them, but its up to you. BY NO MEANS SHOULD YOU GET A PLECO! unless you have a large tank to accomodate it (can reach up to 18-24 inches and produces waste compatible to an oscar...)

flying foxes are cool too but they arent big algae eaters and also like to be in groups (or so i've read).

-Brandon

\\\\\\\"an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of the cure\\\\\\\"
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 03:51Profile PM Edit Delete Report 
Shinigami
 
---------------
---------------
---------------
Ichthyophile
Catfish/Oddball Fan
Posts: 9962
Kudos: 2915
Registered: 22-Feb-2001
male usa us-delaware
Both SAEs and CAEs get too large for a 10 gallon, IMO. I wouldn't keep either in a 10 gallon as a permanent solution.

--------------------------------------------
The aquarist is one who must learn the ways of the biologist, the chemist, and the veterinarian.
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 05:12Profile PM Edit Delete Report 
brandeeno
 
-----
Mega Fish
Posts: 929
Kudos: 636
Registered: 13-Sep-2007
male usa us-california
thats why i mentioned a larger tank or them becoming food after they served their purpose.

I agree both become too large for a 10g for long term, but short term might be ok...

\\\\\\\"an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of the cure\\\\\\\"
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 05:50Profile PM Edit Delete Report 
Cichlid Kid
****
-----
Fish Addict
Posts: 553
Kudos: 285
Votes: 34
Registered: 22-May-2004
male usa
i dont want it to become food, i want it to be a permanent part of my tank to take out algae as it comes, if no algae is present i can enjoy whatever it is by supplementing with veggies and algae wafers.
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 06:08Profile AIM PM Edit Delete Report 
Gourami
********
---------------
Mega Fish
Posts: 1205
Kudos: 477
Votes: 1
Registered: 23-Apr-2002
male usa
I think a trio of ottos would be fine.
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 11:54Profile Homepage AIM MSN PM Edit Delete Report 
Cichlid Kid
****
-----
Fish Addict
Posts: 553
Kudos: 285
Votes: 34
Registered: 22-May-2004
male usa
would it be fine to just get one and try him,then introduce one to two more later?
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 21:24Profile AIM PM Edit Delete Report 
FRANK
 
**********
---------------
---------------
Moderator
Posts: 5108
Kudos: 5263
Votes: 1690
Registered: 28-Dec-2002
male usa us-colorado
EditedEdited by FRANK
Hi,
The short answer is No, it is not a good idea to buy fish
that school or shoal one at a time.
When purchasing that type of fish, and when money is
important, save up until you can purchase the
minimum number of that species. Or, even better,
save until you can purchase the full complement of
that type of fish and introduce them all at once.

Purchasing fish, one or two at a time in a species that
shoal or school, invites disease as you will possibly
be purchasing from different deliveries, and perhaps even
different tanks.
Purchasing fish like this also increases the chances of
a more aggressive "pecking order" as the one or ones in the
tank will have established "ownership" of either the tank
or a specific area that they will defend against the
newcomers.

Frank

-->>> The Confidence of Amateurs, is the Envy of Professionals <<<--
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 22:21Profile PM Edit Delete Report 
Cichlid Kid
****
-----
Fish Addict
Posts: 553
Kudos: 285
Votes: 34
Registered: 22-May-2004
male usa
ok thanks. never looked at it like a pecking order but it makes sense
Post InfoPosted 21-Jan-2009 23:01Profile AIM PM Edit Delete Report 
itsjustme1966
-----
Hobbyist
Posts: 94
Kudos: 36
Votes: 1
Registered: 18-Mar-2008
female canada
I would choose the otto's, 3 for sure for a 10gal.. temps at 75-77 are suitable for these little guys..they adapt well, and do a good job of cleanning up..
offer some DW if you can as they like it to hide its natural for them..wood is best but other hiding places will do too..
Post InfoPosted 22-Jan-2009 03:20Profile PM Edit Delete Report 
Cichlid Kid
****
-----
Fish Addict
Posts: 553
Kudos: 285
Votes: 34
Registered: 22-May-2004
male usa
yes i hear they like DW and broad leaved plant(preferably live) which i have both of.should work out well.
Post InfoPosted 22-Jan-2009 05:52Profile AIM PM Edit Delete Report 
Post Reply  New Topic
Jump to: 

The views expressed on this page are the implied opinions of their respective authors.
Under no circumstances do the comments on this page represent the opinions of the staff of FishProfiles.com.

FishProfiles.com Forums, version 11.0
Mazeguy Smilies